Choosing the right toilet involves balancing performance, comfort, and budget. The TOLO Drake stands out as the best overall pick thanks to its reliable flush and sleek design, while the Gerber Maxwell Select offers excellent value with dual-flush efficiency. For those with specific accessibility needs, models like the Simple Project 21″ Extra Tall Toilet excel in height and ease of use. The main tradeoffs often revolve around price versus features, space considerations, and ease of maintenance. Continue reading for a detailed breakdown of the top options and what to consider before making your decision.
Listen free for 30 days with Audible
Thousands of audiobooks and originals — cancel anytime.
Start your free trialAs an affiliate, we earn on qualifying purchases.
Complete the kit
Key Takeaways
- Efficiency in water use varies widely, with dual-flush models offering significant savings over standard toilets.
- Height and accessibility features are critical for seniors or those with mobility challenges, favoring taller or ADA-compliant options.
- Sleek, skirted designs tend to be easier to clean but may come at a higher price point or require professional installation.
- Not all high-efficiency toilets fit every bathroom layout; measuring rough-in and space is essential before purchasing.
- Price ranges reflect differences in build quality, features, and brand reputation—more expensive options often offer better durability and comfort.
More Details on Our Top Picks
Simple Project 21″ Extra Tall Toilet for Seniors and Handicap
This extra tall toilet prioritizes comfort for seniors and users with mobility issues, standing out from standard-height options like the Gerber Maxwell by offering a taller seat height that reduces strain. Its 21-inch height, combined with a soft-close elongated seat, makes sitting and standing easier, but it limits color choices and is compatible only with 12-inch rough-in plumbing. Compared to typical toilets, this model emphasizes accessibility over style or water efficiency, making it ideal for specialized needs. The quiet, soft-close seat minimizes noise, and the 1.28 GPF flush maintains cleanliness without excessive water use. However, it doesn’t specify water-saving features beyond its flush rate, which could be a concern for eco-conscious buyers.
Pros:- Designed for easy access and comfort for users with mobility issues
- Quiet soft-close seat reduces noise disturbance
- Efficient 1.28 GPF flush maintains cleanliness
Cons:- Limited color options restrict aesthetic flexibility
- Requires standard 12″ rough-in plumbing, limiting installation options
Best for: Seniors, pregnant women, or individuals with mobility challenges seeking a comfortable, accessible toilet.
Not ideal for: Homeowners prioritizing modern design or water efficiency, as it offers limited color options and no advanced eco features.
- Height:21 inches
- Rough-in:12 inches
- Flush Rate:1.28 GPF
- Seat Type:Elongated
- Installation:Easy, with instructions and videos
Our verdict“This toilet is best suited for those needing increased height and accessibility, prioritizing comfort over style or water-saving features.”
Gerber Maxwell Select Elongated Dual-Flush Toilet, White
The Gerber Maxwell Select balances performance and eco-friendliness, featuring a dual-flush system that lets users select between 1.0 and 1.28 GPF, saving water compared to single-flush models like the Simple Project. Its soft-close seat adds convenience, and the tool-free installation makes setup straightforward. Compared with the HOROW T0338W, this model offers dual flushing, making it more versatile for water conservation, but it requires more space for the elongated bowl and comes at a potentially higher initial cost. Its high-quality porcelain and clog-free trapway enhance performance, but the larger footprint may be unsuitable for small bathrooms. Overall, this pick suits those seeking a durable, water-efficient option with modern amenities.
Pros:- Dual-flush system conserves water and lowers utility bills
- Soft-close seat prevents slamming and noise
- Easy, tool-free installation kit included
Cons:- Requires ample space for elongated bowl design
- Higher initial purchase cost compared to basic models
Best for: Homeowners aiming to reduce water bills with a reliable, dual-flush toilet that combines ease of installation.
Not ideal for: Small bathroom spaces or buyers on a tight budget, as it demands more room and has a higher upfront price point.
- Brand:Gerber
- Model Number:GRD49210E
- Color:White
- Type:Two-piece toilet
- Flush Mechanism:Dual-flush (1.0 and 1.28 GPF)
- Seat:Soft-close elongated seat
Our verdict“This toilet is ideal for eco-conscious users who want efficient water use combined with modern convenience features.”
HOROW T0338W One Piece Toilet with ADA Chair Height 17.3″ Dual Flush
The HOROW T0338W stands out for its compact, one-piece design and ADA-compliant 17.3-inch seat height, making it a strong choice for small bathrooms and users seeking ease of use. Its dual-flush system offers 1.1/1.6 GPF options, providing flexibility for different waste loads. Compared with the Casta Diva ADA, it offers a slightly lower height and easier installation with rough-in options, but it requires careful measurement to ensure proper fit. Its fully glazed siphon trapway guarantees efficient flushing, but the compact size might not suit larger or more luxurious bathroom styles. This model suits those prioritizing accessibility and space efficiency while maintaining decent water savings.
Pros:- ADA chair height simplifies sitting and standing
- Compact design fits small bathrooms
- Dual-flush system for water savings
Cons:- Requires precise rough-in measurement for proper fit
- Includes only a soft-close seat, may need additional accessories
Best for: Small bathroom owners, seniors, or those requiring ADA height for better accessibility.
Not ideal for: Larger households or users who prefer a more decorative, less utilitarian design, as its size and style are quite functional.
- Dimensions:26.6″D x 15″W x 26″H
- Seat Height:17.3″
- Flush Options:1.1/1.6 GPF
- Trapway:2″ fully glazed siphon
Our verdict“This toilet offers a combination of space-saving design and accessibility, perfect for small or mobility-challenged bathrooms.”
Gerber Viper Force Elongated Two-Piece Toilet, Soft-Close Seat, White
The Gerber Viper Force emphasizes strong flushing performance with a 1.28 GPF system that reliably clears waste without clogging, outperforming many basic toilets like the Simple Project. Its durable, soft-close elongated seat adds quietness and comfort, and the smooth glazed trapway simplifies cleaning. Compared to the HOROW T0338W, it may lack ADA height but offers a straightforward, powerful flush suitable for high-use households. The absence of height specifications could be a drawback for those needing specific comfort features. The Viper Force is best suited for users who prioritize dependable, clog-free operation over height or advanced eco features.
Pros:- Powerful, clog-free flush system
- Soft-close seat for quiet operation
- Easy to install and clean
Cons:- No height or seat dimension info provided
- Limited color options restrict aesthetic choices
Best for: Busy households or commercial settings needing a reliable, powerful flush with quiet operation.
Not ideal for: Individuals requiring ADA height or specific ergonomic features, as height details are not specified.
- Type:Two-piece toilet
- Color:White
- Flush Rate:1.28 GPF
- Seat:Soft-close elongated
- Trapway:Smooth glazed
Our verdict“This toilet is ideal for those seeking a durable, high-performance flushing system with quiet features for everyday use.”
Casta Diva Elongated One Piece Toilet with 17.2″ ADA Comfort Height Seat
The Casta Diva combines a sleek one-piece design with a potent air-pressure-assisted flush system that operates effectively without electricity. Its ADA-compliant 17.2-inch seat height makes it accessible for users with mobility challenges, providing a comfortable sitting experience. Compared with the HOROW T0338W, it offers a lower water usage at 1.0 GPF, which could be less effective for heavy waste but reduces water consumption significantly. The full installation kit facilitates quick setup, though the absence of electric components means manual operation is needed. Its compact size and modern look make it ideal for contemporary bathrooms, but the lower flush volume may not be suitable for larger households or those with heavy waste loads.
Pros:- Powerful, efficient flush system suitable for low-pressure areas
- ADA comfort height simplifies sitting and standing
- Includes complete installation kit for ease of setup
Cons:- No electric components, manual operation required
- Compact size might not suit larger bathrooms
- Lower 1.0 GPF water usage may reduce flushing effectiveness for heavy waste
Best for: Mobility-impaired users or those seeking a sleek, efficient toilet with powerful flushing in low-pressure environments.
Not ideal for: Large families or heavy waste users who need a higher flush volume for heavy loads or prefer electric-powered systems.
- Flush System:Air-pressure-assisted
- Water Usage:1.0 GPF
- Bowl Shape:Elongated
- Seat Height:17.2 inches
- Dimensions:26.9″D x 15″W x 19.3″H
Our verdict“This model is ideal for users needing ADA height and a modern, efficient flush in a space-conscious design.”
DeerValley Two-Piece ADA Compliant Elongated Toilet with Power Flush and Soft-Close Seat
This toilet stands out for combining ADA-compliant height with a powerful, water-saving flush that rivals the performance of the TOTO Drake, yet it maintains a sleek two-piece design. Its 17 13/16-inch height prioritizes user comfort, especially for those needing easier sitting and standing. The soft-close elongated seat adds convenience, but the two-piece construction can make installation a bit more involved compared to one-piece models like the DeerValley Compact. The limited one-year warranty is a drawback, especially when durability is a concern. However, for homeowners seeking a balance of comfort, efficiency, and style, this model offers an attractive package.
Pros:- Comfortable ADA height for ease of use
- Powerful, water-efficient flush system
- Quiet-close elongated seat for convenience
Cons:- Two-piece design may be less straightforward to install
- Limited warranty duration of one year
Best for: Buyers prioritizing comfort, modern aesthetics, and reliable performance in a versatile bathroom upgrade.
Not ideal for: Those wanting a quick-install, one-piece design or a longer warranty period for peace of mind.
- Rough-in:12 inches
- Flush Rate:1.28 GPF
- Height:17 13/16 inches
- Seat:Elongated, Soft-close
- Material:Porcelain
- Warranty:1 year
Our verdict“This model suits those seeking a comfortable, stylish toilet with strong flushing power and modern features.”
DeerValley Compact One Piece Toilet with Soft-Close Seat, Dual Flush, 12” Rough-In, Skirted Design
Compared with the DeerValley Two-Piece model, this one-piece toilet offers a seamless, easier-to-clean surface that’s ideal for small bathrooms. Its dual-flush system supports water savings, making it a smart choice for eco-conscious households. The skirted design simplifies cleaning, but the 12-inch rough-in limits installation flexibility and may not fit all spaces. Its 250 lbs weight capacity is respectable, yet some users might find the soft-close seat less durable over time. This pick makes the most sense for those needing a compact, efficient solution without sacrificing style or functionality.
Pros:- Space-saving compact design suitable for small bathrooms
- Water-efficient dual flush system reduces water bills
- Easy-to-clean skirted bowl and soft-close seat
Cons:- Less suitable for larger or heavier users
- Limited to 12-inch rough-in space
Best for: Small bathroom owners who want a space-efficient, easy-to-maintain toilet with dual-flush technology.
Not ideal for: Larger or heavier users, or those with limited 12-inch rough-in space looking for more durability or larger models.
- Dimensions:24½”L×13⅜”W×28⅜”H
- Rough-In:12″
- Flush Options:1.1/1.6 GPF
- Weight Capacity:250 lbs
- Seat:Soft-close, quiet (28dB)
Our verdict“This toilet is a practical choice for small bathrooms seeking efficiency, ease of cleaning, and space savings.”
SuperfLo 21 Inch High Elongated Tall Toilet
This toilet’s 21-inch height makes it a standout for tall or senior users, offering enhanced comfort compared to standard models like the DeerValley Two-Piece. Its soft-close seat provides quiet operation, and water-efficient flushing keeps utility bills in check. However, its 12-inch rough-in limits installation options, and it’s not designed for larger or heavier users beyond typical weight capacities. Its focus on accessibility and comfort makes it ideal for those with mobility challenges or tall stature, but it requires precise installation and may lack color options for some buyers.
Pros:- Extra tall height for comfortable seating and standing
- Soft-close, removable seat for quiet operation
- Water-efficient flush technology
Cons:- Limited to standard 12-inch rough-in installations
- No color options mentioned
Best for: Tall users, seniors, or those needing an accessible, comfortable height toilet.
Not ideal for: Buyers with limited rough-in space or seeking a standard-height, more versatile model.
- Height:21 inches
- Rough-in:12 inches
- Flush Volume:1.28 gallons per flush
- Waste Removal:1000 grams
Our verdict“This model is ideal for taller or accessibility-focused bathrooms where comfort and quiet operation are priorities.”
Casta Diva Elongated One Piece Toilet with 17-inch Comfort Chair Height Seat
Compared with the DeerValley Two-Piece, the Casta Diva offers a sleek, one-piece construction that’s easier to clean and maintain, with a seamless surface that resists grime buildup. Its powerful siphon jet flush provides quiet, effective waste removal, and dual-flush options help conserve water. The 17-inch ADA height makes it more comfortable for many users, but installation might require some plumbing expertise, and it’s limited to standard 12-inch rough-in spaces. This model appeals most to those who value hygiene, aesthetics, and water efficiency in a modern bathroom.
Pros:- Seamless, easy-to-clean design
- Powerful and quiet siphon flush
- Water-efficient dual-flush system
Cons:- Installation may require plumbing skills
- Limited to standard 12-inch rough-in
Best for: Homeowners wanting a seamless, easy-to-clean toilet with ADA height and water-saving features.
Not ideal for: Those with limited plumbing knowledge or space constraints beyond 12 inches, or seeking additional features like bidets.
- Type:Elongated One Piece
- Seat Height:17 inches
- Depth:27.17 inches
- Width:14.37 inches
- Flush Rating:1000 grams
- Water Consumption:1.1 GPF (liquids), 1.6 GPF (solids)
Our verdict“This toilet suits those seeking a clean, efficient, and modern design with ADA comfort height.”
One Piece Sleek Modern Toilet, ADA Chair Seat Height 17″, Dual Flush 0.9/1.28 GPF, MAP 1000g, 12″ Rough-In, Compact Fully Skirted Round Toilet for Bathrooms
This fully skirted, one-piece toilet emphasizes space efficiency with its compact round design, making it suitable for tight bathrooms or commercial settings. Its 17-inch ADA chair height enhances comfort, especially for elderly or disabled users. The dual-flush system with a 0.9/1.28 GPF option balances water conservation with performance, while the MAP 1000g siphon flush delivers strong waste removal. Installation might pose challenges due to plumbing specifics, and it doesn’t include water supply components, which could add to the setup time. Still, for those needing a sleek, space-saving, and durable fixture, this model fits the bill.
Pros:- Comfortable 17-inch ADA height seat
- Dual-flush system for water efficiency
- Fully skirted, easy-to-clean design
Cons:- Requires professional installation due to plumbing specifics
- Excludes water supply pipe and floor flange
Best for: Small bathrooms or commercial spaces requiring a compact, ADA-compliant, high-performance toilet.
Not ideal for: Homeowners with larger bathrooms or those seeking a model with included water supply components for easier install.
- Rough-In:12 inches
- Seat Height:17 inches
- Flush Options:0.9/1.28 GPF
- MAP:1000 grams
- Dimensions:25.5″D x 14.7″W x 27″H
- Material:Ceramic
Our verdict“This toilet makes a strong case for space-conscious environments needing ADA comfort and efficient flushing.”
Simple Project 21 inch Elongated Extra Tall Toilet for Seniors
The Simple Project 21 inch Elongated Extra Tall Toilet stands out for its elevated height, making it an excellent choice for seniors and taller individuals who find standard toilets uncomfortable. Compared with the TOTO Drake, which offers a modern design and efficient flushing, this model prioritizes ergonomic comfort over sleek aesthetics, but its taller stature can be a double-edged sword—beneficial for ease of use but potentially challenging for users under 5’4″. The soft-close seat enhances quiet operation, while the water-efficient flush reduces utility bills. However, the two-piece design complicates installation, and its height may be too much for some users, especially those with limited mobility or shorter stature. This toilet is best suited for taller individuals or seniors who need a comfortable, accessible height and don’t mind a slightly more involved setup.
Pros:- Elevated height reduces knee and hip strain, enhancing comfort
- Soft-close seat minimizes noise and sudden closures
- Water-efficient flush conserves water and lowers bills
- Durable high-density ceramic construction
Cons:- Users under 5’4″ may need a footstool for better support
- Two-piece design makes installation more complex
- Height may be too tall for some small bathrooms
Best for: Tall adults and seniors with mobility issues seeking a comfortable, high-height toilet.
Not ideal for: Users under 5’4″ or those with limited space, as the tall profile may cause difficulty or require a footstool.
- Height:21 inches
- Bowl Shape:Elongated
- Rough-In:12 inches
- Flush Rate:1.28 GPF
- Material:High-density ceramic
Our verdict“This toilet is ideal for taller users or seniors prioritizing comfort and accessibility, despite more involved installation and height considerations.”
TOTO Drake Two-Piece Elongated 1.6 GPF Universal Height Tornado Flush Toilet with CEFIONTECT, Cotton White
The TOTO Drake makes a strong case for those seeking a reliable, stylish toilet with minimal maintenance. Its Tornado Flush system provides a powerful swirl that reduces waste buildup, making it easier to clean compared to the simpler flush mechanisms of the Simple Project 21. The universal height offers a comfortable position for most users, blending accessibility with a sleek, modern look. While it excels in efficiency and ease of cleaning, it requires separate purchase of essential parts like the seat and water supply lines, adding to the overall cost and complexity of setup. The left-hand trip lever may not suit everyone’s preference, especially for right-handed users. This model is well-suited for those who want a contemporary aesthetic and low-maintenance operation, though they should be prepared for additional purchases and installation steps.
Pros:- Efficient Tornado Flush minimizes cleaning and waste buildup
- Universal height offers comfort for diverse users
- Water-saving 1.6 GPF reduces water bills
- Stylish, modern appearance with clean lines
Cons:- Seat, wax ring, and supply lines sold separately, increasing upfront cost
- Requires additional hardware for installation
- Left-hand trip lever may not suit all users’ preferences
Best for: Homeowners wanting a stylish, low-maintenance toilet with efficient flushing and universal comfort.
Not ideal for: Those seeking an all-in-one package or with a preference for right-hand trip levers, as parts must be purchased separately and the lever is on the left.
- Flow Rate:1.6 GPF
- Trap Seal:2-1/8″
- Minimum Water Pressure:8 psi
- Height:Universal Height
- Bowl Shape:Elongated
- Color:Cotton White
Our verdict“This toilet is perfect for those who prioritize style, efficiency, and ease of cleaning, provided they are comfortable handling additional parts and installation steps.”
How We Picked
I evaluated these toilets based on a combination of performance, design, ease of installation, water efficiency, and user comfort. Durability and maintenance requirements also played a role, as well as overall value for the features offered. The rankings reflect a balance between these factors, emphasizing models that serve a broad range of needs—from accessibility to modern aesthetics—while prioritizing reliability and ease of use. Cost was considered, but only in relation to features and longevity, ensuring selections are practical and worth the investment for most buyers.Factors to Consider When Choosing Toilets
When selecting a toilet, understanding key factors like water efficiency, comfort, and installation requirements ensures you make a choice that suits your needs and space. The right toilet can improve bathroom hygiene, reduce water bills, and enhance your daily routine. Being aware of common pitfalls, such as choosing the wrong size or neglecting accessibility features, can prevent costly mistakes. This guide highlights crucial considerations to help you navigate the options and find a toilet that balances performance with your budget.Size and Rough-In Measurements
Accurate measurement of your bathroom space is vital. The rough-in, typically 12 inches but sometimes 10 or 14, determines whether a standard or compact model fits. Installing a toilet that’s too large or too small can lead to awkward gaps or difficulty fitting. Always measure the distance from the wall to the center of the drain before purchasing. Compact or corner models are available for tighter spaces, but they require precise sizing to ensure proper fit and function.
Water Efficiency and Flush Technology
Many modern toilets feature dual-flush systems that save water by providing a light flush for liquids and a full flush for solids. Choosing a high-efficiency model can significantly lower water bills while maintaining performance. However, some cheaper models may clog more often or require frequent repairs. Consider the flush mechanism—gravity-fed versus pressure-assisted—as this impacts both performance and noise levels. The goal is to balance water savings with a reliable, strong flush that minimizes maintenance.
Comfort and Height
Comfort can vary widely based on seat height and design. ADA-compliant models are ideal for users with mobility issues or for households seeking easier accessibility. Chair-height toilets, typically around 17-19 inches, reduce strain and ease sitting down or standing up, especially for seniors. Keep in mind that taller models may not fit in every bathroom, so measuring your space and considering user needs is essential. Comfort features often come at a premium but can significantly improve daily usability.
Design and Aesthetics
Toilets come in various styles—traditional, modern, elongated, round, and skirted. A sleek, skirted design offers easier cleaning and a streamlined look but may be more expensive and harder to replace parts on. Elongated bowls tend to be more comfortable, especially for adults, but require more space. Consider your bathroom’s decor and your maintenance preferences when choosing a style. Remember, a well-chosen design can enhance your bathroom’s appearance and simplify cleaning routines.
Installation and Maintenance
Some toilets are designed for DIY installation, featuring straightforward bolt patterns and clear instructions. Others, especially those with complex features or specific dimensions, may require professional help. Regular maintenance involves checking for leaks, cleaning the bowl and seat, and occasionally replacing flapper or seal parts. Choosing a model with accessible parts and straightforward installation can save time and money in the long run. Be mindful of your skill level and the complexity of the model you select.
Frequently Asked Questions
How do I know if a toilet will fit in my bathroom?
Measuring your space accurately is the first step. Focus on the rough-in measurement, which is the distance from the wall to the center of the drain pipe—most are 12 inches, but some can be 10 or 14. Also, consider the overall width and height, especially if you have limited space or specific accessibility needs. Choosing a compact or corner model can help in tight spaces, but always double-check measurements against the product specifications before purchasing.
Are dual-flush toilets worth the extra cost?
Dual-flush toilets generally offer better water savings over traditional single-flush models, which can translate into lower utility bills over time. They provide a choice between a light and full flush, making them more environmentally friendly and cost-effective. However, they tend to be more expensive upfront and may sometimes clog if not properly designed. For households aiming to reduce water use without sacrificing performance, dual-flush toilets often prove a worthwhile investment.
What is the best height for a toilet for seniors?
For seniors or individuals with mobility challenges, a chair-height or ADA-compliant toilet—around 17 to 19 inches tall—typically offers the most comfort and safety. These heights reduce the effort needed to sit down and stand up, decreasing the risk of falls or strain. Choosing a model with sturdy support features or soft-close seats can further enhance safety and comfort, making daily routines easier and more secure.
How important is the bowl shape in choosing a toilet?
The shape of the bowl influences comfort and space requirements. Elongated bowls tend to be more comfortable for adults, offering more seating area, while round bowls are more space-efficient, suitable for smaller bathrooms. Your choice should balance comfort preferences with your bathroom dimensions. Additionally, elongated bowls can be slightly more expensive and may require more room, so measure carefully before choosing.
Do I need professional help to install a new toilet?
Many standard toilets are designed for straightforward installation, which a DIY-savvy homeowner can handle with basic tools. However, if your bathroom plumbing is outdated, involves complex configurations, or if you opt for a high-tech or custom model, professional installation can prevent costly mistakes. Proper installation ensures the toilet functions correctly and reduces the risk of leaks or damage, making professional help a sensible choice for complex setups or if you’re unsure of your skills.
Conclusion
For most households, the TOLO Drake offers the best balance of reliability, comfort, and style, making it ideal as the best overall choice. Those seeking the best value might prefer the Gerber Maxwell Select, which combines efficiency with affordability. If you need a model specifically for accessibility or seniors, the Simple Project 21″ Extra Tall Toilet is a standout. For buyers willing to invest more in premium features and sleek design, models like the TOTO Drake deliver top-tier performance and durability. Consider your bathroom size, budget, and specific needs to find the best fit.
NFL season / tailgating Picks
team gear
As an affiliate, we earn on qualifying purchases.
