Choosing the right 12×24 shed from Astoria involves balancing customization, included features, and build quality. The Handy Home Products Astoria stands out for those wanting a DIY project with flexibility, but it requires purchasing a floor, shingles, and paint separately. Meanwhile, the Astoria 12×24 Wooden Storage Shed with Floor Kit offers a ready-to-assemble package that includes a floor, making it ideal for immediate setup. Both options deliver ample vertical storage space, but they differ significantly in what’s included and customization potential. Here’s how I compare these two top choices to help you decide which aligns best with your needs.
Prime for Young Adults — start your free trial
Fast free delivery, streaming and member deals for eligible 18–24 year olds.
Try it freeAs an affiliate, we earn on qualifying purchases.
Complete the kit
Key Takeaways
- The Handy Home version offers more customization options but lacks a pre-installed floor and roofing materials.
- The included floor kit in the second option simplifies assembly, saving time and effort.
- Both sheds share similar dimensions and durable wood framing, but they cater to different DIY skill levels.
- Paint and shingles are sold separately for both, impacting overall project cost.
- Choosing between them depends on whether you prioritize customization or convenience.
| Handy Home Products Astoria 12×24 Do-It-Yourself Wooden Storage Shed- Does not Include Floor kit, Paint, or Roofing Shingles |  | Best for DIY enthusiasts seeking customization | Size: 12×24 feet | Wall Height: 7 feet | Peak Height: 9’11” | VIEW ON AMAZON | See Our Full Breakdown |
| Astoria 12×24 Wooden Storage Shed with Floor Kit |  | Best for those seeking a ready-to-assemble shed with included flooring | Size: 12×24 feet | Wall Height: 7 feet | Peak Height: 9’11” | VIEW ON AMAZON | See Our Full Breakdown |
| astoria 12×24 shed review | Size | Wall Height | Peak Height | Door Width |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Handy Home Products Astoria 12 | 12×24 feet | 7 feet | 9’11" | 5’4" |
| Astoria 12×24 Wooden Storage S | 12×24 feet | 7 feet | 9’11" | 5’4" |
More Details on Our Top Picks
Handy Home Products Astoria 12×24 Do-It-Yourself Wooden Storage Shed- Does not Include Floor kit, Paint, or Roofing Shingles
This shed appeals to those comfortable with building projects who want full control over the final look. Its absence of a floor and roofing materials means you can tailor the foundation and exterior to your preferences, whether that’s a concrete pad or a specific roofing style. The 7-foot side walls and peak height of nearly 10 feet provide generous vertical space for tools and equipment, especially for taller items like ladders. However, the need to purchase and install a floor, shingles, and paint separately increases the overall effort and cost. Compared with the second option, it offers greater flexibility but demands more DIY skill and planning.
Pros:- Complete customization potential for foundation and exterior finish
- Large vertical space suitable for tall equipment
- Premium 2×4 framing ensures structural integrity
Cons:- Floor, shingles, and paint sold separately, increasing total cost
- Requires more DIY expertise and effort
- No included roofing materials for immediate weatherproofing
Best for: DIYers who want a fully customizable shed and are willing to handle installation details.
Not ideal for: Buyers seeking a turnkey solution with everything included for quick assembly.
- Size:12×24 feet
- Wall Height:7 feet
- Peak Height:9’11”
- Door Width:5’4″
- Material:Wood
- Includes:None (requires purchase of floor, shingles, paint)
Our verdict“This shed is best for experienced DIYers who want total control over customization and are prepared for a more involved project.”
Astoria 12×24 Wooden Storage Shed with Floor Kit
This model simplifies the building process by including a sturdy floor kit, making it a strong choice for those who want a more straightforward setup. Its dimensions and peak height match the first option, providing ample vertical storage, with the added benefit of a pre-installed floor that facilitates immediate use. While the shed still requires purchase of shingles and paint separately, the inclusion of the floor reduces the total project complexity. Compared to the DIY-only option, this shed suits buyers who prefer a balance of customization with convenience, especially if they want to avoid extensive framing work.
Pros:- Includes a durable floor kit for quick setup
- Ample vertical space for large equipment
- Customizable door placement and trim options
Cons:- Paint and shingles sold separately, adding to costs
- Assembly still required and may be time-consuming
- Limited to standard features without extensive customization options
Best for: Homeowners who want a durable, ready-to-assemble shed with minimal foundation worries.
Not ideal for: Very experienced DIYers looking for maximum customization or those on a strict budget that excludes the floor kit.
- Size:12×24 feet
- Wall Height:7 feet
- Peak Height:9’11”
- Door Width:5’4″
- Material:Wood
- Includes:Floor Kit
Our verdict“This shed offers a practical, easy-to-assemble solution with built-in flooring, ideal for homeowners prioritizing convenience over complete customization.”
How We Picked
My evaluation focused on the core needs of typical shed buyers: build quality, included features, customization flexibility, and value for money. I compared the sheds’ dimensions, framing, and accessories, considering how each product suits different user preferences—whether they prefer a fully customizable project or a ready-to-assemble solution. I also examined tradeoffs like the need for additional purchases and ease of assembly, aiming to identify options that stand out for specific buyer types.
| astoria 12×24 shed review | Includes |
|---|---|
| Handy Home Products Astoria 12 | None (requires purchase of floor, shingles, paint) |
| Astoria 12×24 Wooden Storage S | Floor Kit |
Factors to Consider When Choosing Astoria 12×24 Shed Review
When choosing an Astoria 12×24 shed, the key factors revolve around your DIY skills, need for customization, and how quickly you want to start using your shed. Both options provide similar dimensions and a sturdy wood frame, but they differ in what’s included and how much work is required to complete the build. To help you decide, I’ve broken down the main considerations that influence whether a shed is a good fit for your project and lifestyle.
Included Features and Customization
Consider whether you prefer a shed that comes with everything ready to assemble or one that offers maximum customization. The second option, with its included floor kit, reduces the complexity of foundation work, making it suitable for those who want a straightforward build. Conversely, the DIY-only model allows for complete personalization of the foundation and exterior but requires more planning and effort.
Ease of Assembly
If you prioritize quick setup and minimal hassle, the shed with a floor kit is the better choice. It simplifies the process by including a durable base, reducing the number of steps needed before use. The DIY-only shed, while flexible, demands more time, carpentry skills, and additional purchases, which could extend your project timeline.
Cost and Future Expenses
Both sheds require you to buy shingles and paint separately, but the DIY-only option might incur additional costs for foundation materials and labor if you hire help. The shed with a floor kit could save money on foundation prep and speed up installation, but overall costs depend heavily on your choice of exterior finishes and roofing materials.
Durability and Material Quality
Both options feature 2×4 wood framing, ensuring solid structural integrity. Your decision may hinge on whether you want to invest more upfront for a ready-to-assemble solution or enjoy the flexibility to build exactly to your specifications from the ground up. Durability is comparable, provided you apply appropriate paint and shingles eventually.
Frequently Asked Questions
Do I need a building permit for a 12×24 shed?
Whether you need a permit depends on your local regulations, which vary widely. Many municipalities require permits for structures over a certain size or for sheds that are not entirely portable. It’s advisable to check with your local building authority before purchasing or starting construction to avoid fines or required modifications later.
Can I customize the exterior of these sheds?
Yes, both sheds are designed for exterior customization. You can paint or stain the wood to match your property’s aesthetic, and shingles are sold separately, allowing you to choose a style that suits your climate and design preferences. The DIY-only shed offers more flexibility for custom siding or additional exterior modifications, while the shed with the floor kit is more suited for straightforward finishes.
How difficult is assembly for these sheds?
The shed with the floor kit generally offers easier assembly because it includes the foundation, reducing foundational work. The DIY-only version requires more carpentry skills, framing, and careful planning, making it better suited for experienced builders or those willing to invest additional time and effort. Both will require at least some basic tools and patience.
Are the materials weather-resistant?
Both sheds are built with high-quality wood framing designed to withstand typical weather conditions when properly painted or sealed. Applying a weatherproof finish is recommended to prolong their lifespan, especially if your area experiences heavy rain or snow. The inclusion of shingles, when purchased and installed correctly, will further improve weather resistance.
What maintenance is required for these sheds?
Regular maintenance includes inspecting the exterior paint or stain, sealing any gaps, and replacing shingles as needed. Keeping the shed clean and free of debris will also help prevent moisture buildup and wood rot. The shed with the floor kit may require less foundation maintenance, but both will benefit from annual inspections and upkeep.
Conclusion
For buyers who enjoy hands-on projects and want full control over the shed’s foundation and finish, the DIY-only Handy Home Astoria is the ideal option, despite requiring more effort. If you prefer a faster, more straightforward setup with a pre-installed floor, the Astoria 12×24 Wooden Storage Shed with Floor Kit offers excellent value and ease of assembly. Budget-conscious buyers should consider total costs, including shingles and paint, while those seeking maximum customization and a custom foundation will find the DIY model more appealing. Ultimately, your choice depends on your skill level, timeline, and how much you want to tailor your shed’s appearance and foundation.
Fall yard work Picks
leaf blowers
As an affiliate, we earn on qualifying purchases.
